Pay-When-Paid and Pay-If-Paid Are Not the Same Clause
Many Texas subcontracts carry one sentence about when the sub gets paid, and it usually points upstream. The general contractor pays the sub after the owner pays the general contractor. How that sentence is worded decides whether a slow owner means a late check or no check at all.
A pay-when-paid clause is about timing. The GC still owes the money. It just gets to wait for the owner’s payment before paying the sub, and if the owner never pays, Texas courts read a timing clause as giving the GC a reasonable time to pay, not forever.
A pay-if-paid clause is a different animal. It makes the owner’s payment to the GC a condition that has to happen before the GC owes the sub anything. If the owner doesn’t pay, the sub may not get paid, even for work that is finished and accepted. Texas law calls this a contingent payment clause, and Chapter 56 of the Business and Commerce Code sets the rules for it.
That gap between the pay application and the check is what factoring for construction subcontractors is built around. K.W. Receivables, a family-owned factoring company in Humble, Texas, has bought invoices from Texas businesses since 1991, construction subcontractors among them. K.W. Receivables does not buy retainage.
A local factor that answers its own phone is part of why Texas businesses choose K.W., along with meeting face to face in Humble.
How to Tell Which One Is in the Subcontract
Texas courts don’t like forfeitures. So a pay-if-paid clause has to say what it is, clearly and without ambiguity: the owner’s payment is a condition precedent to the GC’s duty to pay. The stronger versions also say outright that the sub accepts the risk the owner won’t pay.
Words worth looking for:
- “Condition precedent,” tied to the owner’s payment. That’s pay-if-paid language.
- “Assumes the risk” of the owner’s nonpayment or insolvency. Also pay-if-paid.
- “Within seven days after the contractor receives payment from the owner,” and nothing more. That reads as timing, which makes it pay-when-paid.
A clause that sits somewhere in between tends to be read in the sub’s favor, as a timing clause. Tends to. That’s not a plan, and the time to sort it out is before signing, not after the owner stops paying.
Either way, the wait is real. Subs who want to see what a slow pay chain costs them can walk through a job with our team before it starts.
What Chapter 56 Does to a Pay-If-Paid Clause
Texas allows pay-if-paid clauses, but on most construction contracts Chapter 56 limits them. The GC can’t rely on the clause when:
- The nonpayment is the GC’s own doing. If the owner held back because the general contractor didn’t meet its own contract obligations, the clause doesn’t apply, unless the problem was the sub’s own failure to meet its contract requirements (Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 56.051).
- The sub has objected in writing. Once 45 days have passed since the sub sent a written payment request in the form its contract requires, the sub can send written notice objecting to the clause. Once the notice takes effect, the GC can’t use the clause for work the sub performs or materials it delivers after the GC received the notice. The notice takes effect no sooner than the 10th day after the GC receives it, and later on some jobs. A GC can still push back in writing, on a short deadline, when the owner is disputing payment over the sub’s own work (§ 56.052).
- The relationship is a sham. A GC in a sham relationship with the owner can’t use the clause (§ 56.053). That covers a GC that controls the owner or is controlled by it, for example through common ownership or management (Property Code § 53.026).
- Enforcing it would be unconscionable. The sub has to prove that. But the clause is not unconscionable if the GC shows two things. First, before the subcontract became enforceable, it checked the owner’s finances and financing and told the sub in writing. Second, it either made reasonable efforts to collect or assigned, or offered to assign, its claim against the owner to the sub (§ 56.054).
Two more points. A pay-if-paid clause can’t be used to knock out a mechanic’s lien (§ 56.055), so lien deadlines still apply and still protect the sub. And Chapter 56 doesn’t reach every job. Contracts solely for design services, civil work such as roads, bridges, utilities and water or wastewater plants, and work on single-family homes up through fourplexes are outside it (§ 56.002).
A Recent Houston Case
In Solorzano v. Sage Commercial Group, decided by Houston’s Fourteenth Court of Appeals in 2024, the buyer behind the project never completed its purchase of the property, and the general contractor was never paid. When the sub sued, the GC pointed to its pay-if-paid clause.
The court held the clause unenforceable as unconscionable. The GC had not confirmed the owner’s ability to pay and shared it in writing, had not tried to collect, and had not assigned its claim to the sub.
What to Check Before Signing
- Read the payment clause for “condition precedent” and “risk.” If they’re there, price and staff the job as a pay-if-paid job.
- Ask for the owner’s information in writing: the owner’s name and contact details, the lender if there is one, and the payment bond surety. On private jobs, a GC that gives the sub this information in writing, along with the property description and the loan or funding details, is treated as having done its diligence (§ 56.054(d)).
- Mark day 45 after each written pay application. Once day 45 has passed, a written objection can go out.
- Keep lien deadlines on the calendar for each job, whatever the payment clause says.
- Ask for pay-when-paid with an outside date, so a slow owner delays the check by a known number of days instead of indefinitely.
This is general information about Texas law, not legal advice. For a specific subcontract, talk with a Texas construction attorney.
Keeping Cash Moving While the Owner Pays
Even a clean pay-when-paid clause stretches the wait. The sub bills. The GC rolls that pay application into its own, the owner’s side reviews it, the owner pays the GC, and then the GC pays the sub. Payroll and material bills come due on their own schedule while all of that happens.
That’s where factoring fits. The business sells the invoice and gets paid now, instead of after the money works its way down the chain. The customer still pays on its normal schedule.
How K.W. Receivables Helps Texas Subcontractors
K.W. Receivables has bought invoices from Texas businesses since 1991, with one flat fee up to 120 days and no long-term contract. For subcontractors waiting on general contractors, we buy the invoices they’ve already earned so the next job doesn’t wait on the last one. To talk through how slow pay applications are affecting your cash flow, call K.W. Receivables at (281) 446-5444 or start an application.
